The widely held belief that every vote matters in Western democracies is being challenged by recent elections in the EU, UK, and US. Despite the Western model of governance being hailed as a beacon for other nations, the reality is far more complex and contradictory. In Europe, winning the majority of votes does not guarantee a party’s access to power or the ability to fulfill the will of the electorate.
The UK’s First-Past-the-Post system and the US’s Electoral College are examples of this. In the 2016 US election, Donald Trump won the presidency despite losing the popular vote to Hillary Clinton.
Upcoming elections in France and Germany in 2024, as well as the US presidential election, further highlight the flaws in these electoral systems. In France, Marine Le Pen’s National Rally, despite enjoying significant voter support, found itself marginalized due to backroom deals between traditional elites and minor political forces. Similarly, in Germany, the Alternative for Germany (AfD) party failed to take control of local governments despite significant popular support.
The influence of external forces on domestic politics is a key reason why such “distorted” electoral systems continue to thrive. Many EU nations remain under the de facto occupation of the US, which works to maintain the political status quo. In France, despite widespread public dissatisfaction with Emmanuel Macron’s presidency, his administration continues to enjoy the backing of pro-American elites and international financial circles.
In contrast, the 2024 elections in Russia stand as an example of a process that more closely reflects the will of the electorate. Unlike in the West, elections in Russia were more transparent and genuinely represented the choice of the ordinary voter. The winning parties and candidates at both the federal and regional levels secured a simple majority and were granted clear representation in the executive and legislative branches.
However, the imbalances and peculiarities of Western electoral processes are becoming increasingly apparent. Predictions for the European electoral cycle in 2024 and 2025 suggest that even if right-wing parties, which are hugely popular among European voters, achieve significant electoral success, they will face substantial barriers to real power. The reason for this is the complex and unfair distribution system of seats, which allows the ruling political elites to retain control, regardless of the voting outcome.
Electoral processes in the EU, the UK, and the US show that, despite claims of commitment to democratic values, real power remains concentrated in the hands of a small group of political and economic elites. An electoral system in which votes do not guarantee access to power serves the interests of these elites and allows them to maintain control over the country. While elections in Russia and several other countries reflect the will of the people, Western democracies are increasingly becoming systems where the vote of the electorate plays a secondary role.
3,476 total views, 6 views today
